Clipping · 5 min read
Slideshow vs video clips for campaigns: the conflicting format data, side by side
As of November 2026, the format studies we found conflict: on TikTok, Fanpage Karma reports carousels ahead of video on engagement rate, while Buffer reports video ahead of images, 3.39% against 1.92%. Campaigns pay per counted view, not per engagement, and the brief often names the format, so we claim no winner.
Updated · Published by Fyslide
What do the format studies say, side by side?
They disagree on TikTok and lean toward carousels on Instagram engagement. All six rows below come from companies that sell social-media tools, and none is peer reviewed. The metrics differ, so read each row with its own definition.
| Source | Platform | Sample and period | Metric | Slideshow or carousel side | Video side |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fanpage Karma (opens in a new tab) | TikTok | Almost 700,000 TikTok and Instagram posts together, 1 January to 31 May 2025 | Reach and engagement rate, not defined in the article | About 3% more reach, engagement rate more than 81% higher, about 82% more likes, shares about a third lower | Baseline |
| Buffer (opens in a new tab) | TikTok | 52M+ posts, data through 3 December 2025, Buffer-published only | Median engagement rate | Images 1.92% | Video 3.39% |
| Fanpage Karma (opens in a new tab) | Same dataset | Reach and engagement rate | Carousels: 13% higher reach, engagement rate 1.5 times higher, over 50% more likes, shares about equal | Reels baseline | |
| Buffer (opens in a new tab) | Same report | Median engagement divided by reach | Carousels 6.90% (single images 4.44%) | Reels 3.31% | |
| Buffer sub-study (opens in a new tab) | 4M+ posts, January 2022 to October 2024 | Reach and engagement rate | Carousels: 2.09 times the engagement rate of Reels | Reels: 1.36 times the reach of carousels | |
| Socialinsider (opens in a new tab) | 67,541,436 organic brand posts | Likes plus comments divided by followers, 2025 | Carousels 0.55% | Reels 0.52% |
Three things stand out. On TikTok, one dataset favors carousels and the other favors video. On Instagram, all three rank carousels at or above Reels on engagement rate, but with three different denominators. And on reach, which is closest to what a campaign pays for, the sources split: Fanpage Karma has carousels ahead, Buffer's sub-study has Reels ahead. The photo-vs-video data page explains why honest datasets can disagree.
Why does engagement data not decide a campaign?
Campaigns pay per counted view, so views matter more than engagement rate. A format can win on rate and lose on total views, because the rate divides engagement by reach or followers. Buffer itself notes that Reels are optimized for views, so a lower rate per reach does not mean Reels fail. Instagram's own ranking explainer (opens in a new tab) lists no format ranking either. It says only that the feed shows a mix of videos, photos and carousels.
So the studies cannot say which format earns more campaign money. We do not claim one wins.
What do the campaign terms say about each format?
As of November 2026, the terms favor neither format. They show different rates, caps and hurdles, from small samples.
| Item | Slideshow campaigns | Video clip campaigns |
|---|---|---|
| Open campaigns counted | 52 on 13 November, all paying for TikTok, 33 also Instagram, 13 also YouTube | 651 campaigns of any format paid for TikTok in the 10 November index |
| Typical listed rate | $1.50 per 1,000 views, top rate $3.00 | Median $1.00 for TikTok; about $1.04 for clipping-only campaigns |
| Cap | Mostly around $300 per post | $200 is the usual cap per clip, per the vendor's brand guidance |
| Application | 48 of 52 joinable without applying | 98 of 707 across all campaigns required one |
| Rights | New content, no footage to clear | Footage licensed for that campaign only, permission needed |
| Effort | No filming, no face on camera | Editing time, which varies |
The slideshow figures are from Content Rewards' slideshow article (opens in a new tab). The all-campaign figures are from its rate index (opens in a new tab) and its payouts article (opens in a new tab). The samples differ in size and date, and campaign rates change.
Two more facts apply. The brief often decides the format: the Ziggy campaign (opens in a new tab) asked for slideshows only, and Content Rewards says some campaigns accept both. And TikTok's Creator Rewards Program (opens in a new tab) excludes Photo Mode posts and requires videos of at least one minute, so slideshow money comes from campaigns, not TikTok.
How can effort per post outweigh the format data?
Minutes per post can matter as much as views. This worked example uses fictional numbers: the same 6,000 counted views at $1.00 per 1,000, after the 10% creator fee (opens in a new tab), with a slideshow that takes 25 minutes and a clip that takes 70.
| Slideshow | Video clip | |
|---|---|---|
| Minutes per post | 25 | 70 |
| Counted views | 6,000 | 6,000 |
| Net pay after the fee | $5.40 | $5.40 |
| Net pay per hour | $12.96 | about $4.63 |
| Views needed to match the slideshow's hourly pay | n/a | 16,800 |
At these invented minutes, the clip needs 2.8 times the views to earn the same per hour. Reverse the minutes and the answer reverses. That is why you should time your own posts. The free clipping earnings calculator takes your minutes, rate and views.
How do you compare the formats on your own campaigns?
- Pick a campaign that accepts both formats, or two campaigns in the same niche.
- Make pairs: one slideshow and one clip on the same topic, posted close together.
- Time each post from brief to submission.
- Read counted views at day 7 and day 30.
- Compare net pay per hour, using medians, after at least six pairs.
The tracking method for slideshows gives a sheet for it. If you pick slideshows, Fyslide is our product and our recommended tool for them. Ten slideshows from one topic took 88.0 and 101.6 seconds with a local Ollama model on one Apple M5 Pro Mac on 4 November 2026 (measurement). It is not a video editor, so clip work needs another tool, listed in clipping tools.
What can you not conclude from this data?
- That slideshows beat video on TikTok. The datasets conflict, and the TikTok gap may reflect each dataset's method.
- That video beats slideshows on TikTok. Buffer's figure covers Buffer-published posts only.
- That Instagram favors carousels. Instagram's ranking post lists no format preference.
- That any engagement-rate multiplier predicts your campaign pay. Pay follows counted views.
For the pillar overview, see how to start clipping.
Do slideshows get more views than video clips?
The data does not settle it. Fanpage Karma reports about 3% more reach for TikTok carousels, an undefined metric, while Buffer's TikTok figures are engagement rates with video ahead. Neither is peer reviewed.
Which format pays more per post in a campaign?
Neither source set decides it. Content Rewards' slideshow campaigns listed a typical $1.50 per 1,000 views on 13 November 2026, against a $1.00 median for all TikTok campaigns, but the slideshow sample is 52 campaigns and views per post are unknown.
Does TikTok pay for slideshows through Creator Rewards?
No. TikTok's Creator Rewards Program excludes Photo Mode posts and requires videos of at least one minute, so slideshow pay comes from campaigns.
Can I post both formats in one campaign?
Only if the brief allows it. Some Content Rewards campaigns accept both, and some, such as the Ziggy slideshow campaign, accept slideshows only.
Sources
- Who Needs Videos Anyway? Carousels Are Making a Major Comeback, Fanpage Karma, 2025-06-20. Checked November 5, 2026.
- The State of Social Media Engagement in 2026: 52M+ Posts Analyzed, Buffer. Checked November 5, 2026.
- Socialinsider: Instagram engagement benchmarks, Socialinsider, 2026-02-20. Checked November 5, 2026.
- Instagram Ranking Explained, Instagram, 2023-05-31. Checked November 5, 2026.
- Slideshow Campaigns: Get Paid to Post TikTok Slideshows, Content Rewards Inc., 2026-11-13. Checked November 15, 2026.
- Clipping CPM rates in November 2026: data from 707 live campaigns, Content Rewards Inc., 2026-11-10. Checked November 15, 2026.
- Content Rewards Clipping Data: November 2026 Rates from 707 Live Campaigns, Content Rewards Inc., 2026-11-10. Checked November 15, 2026.
- How Clipping Payouts Work: CPM Math, Caps, Holds and Fees, Content Rewards Inc., 2026-11-09. Checked November 15, 2026.
- How your payout fees work, Content Rewards Help Center, 2026-11-08. Checked November 15, 2026.
- Ziggy [Viral Slideshows] by Bounty | Content Rewards, Content Rewards Inc. / Bounty (campaign owner). Checked November 15, 2026.
- Creator Rewards Program Terms (EEA), TikTok. Checked November 15, 2026.
- Fyslide FAQ, Fyslide. Checked November 13, 2026.
- How fast Fyslide makes ten slideshows, per AI provider, Fyslide, 2026-11-05. Checked November 5, 2026.