Fyslide

Strategy · 5 min read

Instagram carousel vs Reel: what three engagement datasets report, and their limits

As of November 2026, three vendor datasets rank Instagram carousels at or above Reels on engagement rate: Buffer 6.90% against 3.31% per reach, Socialinsider 0.55% against 0.52% per follower (2025), Fanpage Karma 1.5 times with no definition. On reach they conflict, and Instagram names no format preference.

Updated · Published by Fyslide

Do Instagram carousels get more engagement than Reels?

In the three vendor datasets we read in November 2026, carousels score at or above Reels on engagement rate. On reach, the datasets disagree. None of them is peer reviewed, and each measures "engagement" differently, so the table lists the metric next to every number.

DatasetSample and periodMetricCarouselsReels
Buffer, State of Social Media Engagement in 2026 (opens in a new tab)52M+ posts, data through 3 December 2025, published through BufferMedian engagement rate, engagements divided by reach6.90% (single images 4.44%)3.31%
Buffer sub-study, same report4M+ Instagram posts, January 2022 to October 2024Multiples of reach and of engagement rate2.09 times the engagement rate of Reels1.36 times the reach of carousels
Socialinsider Instagram benchmarks (opens in a new tab)67,541,436 organic brand postsLikes plus comments, divided by followers0.55% in 2025, 0.55% in 20240.52% in 2025, 0.50% in 2024
Fanpage Karma study (opens in a new tab)Almost 700,000 TikTok and Instagram posts together, 1 January to 31 May 2025Engagement rate, not defined in the article1.5 times the engagement rate of Reels, 13% higher reach, over 50% more likesShares about equal

Look at reach: Buffer's sub-study (opens in a new tab) has Reels ahead, while Fanpage Karma (opens in a new tab) has carousels 13% ahead. Different samples, periods and definitions can produce that, and neither page settles which is right.

What does each study measure, and what are its limits?

Buffer divides by reach, Socialinsider divides by followers, and Fanpage Karma does not say what it divides by.

  • Buffer. The rates divide engagements by reach, and the posts were published through Buffer by accounts that posted at least 10 times in the past year across at least 4 weeks. Buffer calls its report "not a full-platform view" (opens in a new tab) and notes that Reels are optimized for views, so a lower rate per reach does not mean Reels fail. The report's highlights line says carousels earn "12% more engagement" than Reels, while its detailed section gives about 109%, so we quote the detailed figures with their definition.
  • Socialinsider. The formula is likes plus comments divided by followers, for brand accounts only (opens in a new tab). Saves and shares are not in it, and the denominator is followers, not reach. Its methodology text is inconsistent about follower bands. The same page lists 0.50% for carousels and 0.35% for images in Q3 2026.
  • Fanpage Karma. A five-month window (opens in a new tab) in 2025, with no stated profile count, account-size or industry mix, and no definition of engagement rate.

A fourth source, a search summary of a Socialinsider engagement report, says Reels drive more comments and shares and carousels have the highest save rate. We read only its methodology text, so we do not use that claim.

Why can carousels lead on rate while Reels lead on reach?

Because a rate divides by something. Here is an example with fictional numbers.

ReelCarousel
Accounts reached8,0002,000
Engagements240140
Engagement rate per reach3.0%7.0%

The Reel earns 3 engagements per 100 accounts reached and the carousel earns 7. The carousel wins on rate. The Reel wins on reach and on the total number of engagements. A study that reports only one of the two can look like it contradicts a study that reports the other.

Switch the denominator to followers, as Socialinsider does, and the ranking can change again. That is why a bare "carousels get 2x the engagement" without the dataset, the metric and the sample is not usable.

Does Instagram say it ranks carousels higher than Reels?

No. Instagram's ranking explainer of 31 May 2023 lists no format ranking (opens in a new tab) of carousels, photos and Reels, and says only that the feed shows a mix of videos, photos and carousels. Any carousel advantage you read about comes from vendor data like the table above, not from a platform statement. The details are in how Instagram ranks carousels.

Two platform facts matter when you compare formats. As of November 2026, Instagram's Help Center (opens in a new tab) says videos inside a carousel are not Reels and do not appear in the Reels tab. It also says likes and comments apply to the whole post, so slide-level engagement is not separated.

Which format should you post, and how do you test it?

Use the table as a menu of things to test, not as an instruction.

If you care most aboutWhat the datasets point toWhat to test
Reaching people who do not follow youBuffer's sub-study has Reels ahead on reach, Fanpage Karma has the oppositeThe same topic as a Reel and as a carousel
Engagement rate (per reach or per follower, depending on the study)All three have carousels at or above ReelsA carousel built on the hook of your best Reel
Saves and sharesNo dataset we could read states this reliablyCount your own saves and shares per post

To compare on your own account:

  1. Pick one topic and make it in both formats, posted close together.
  2. Choose one metric and one denominator, and write them down.
  3. Read both posts at the same age, such as 48 hours.
  4. Repeat for five or six topics and compare medians, not your best pair.

The logging method turns this into a sheet, and testing hooks covers what to vary first. For the same question on TikTok, see TikTok photo posts vs videos.

If you make carousels in volume, Fyslide (our product) exports PNG or JPG slides, the caption and a zip to a folder you choose, and you upload them in the Instagram app yourself. Instagram posting is Coming soon in the app, an update that your lifetime access includes. The export guide shows the steps.

Do Instagram carousels get more engagement than Reels?

In three vendor datasets, carousels score at or above Reels on engagement rate. Buffer reports medians of 6.90% against 3.31% per reach, and Socialinsider reports 0.55% against 0.52% per follower for 2025. None is peer reviewed and the metrics differ.

Do Reels get more reach than carousels?

The datasets conflict. Buffer's sub-study of 4M+ posts found Reels with 1.36 times the reach of carousels, while Fanpage Karma reported carousels with 13% higher reach in a different sample.

Is a video inside a carousel a Reel?

No. As of November 2026, Instagram's Help Center says videos inside a carousel are not Reels and do not appear in the Reels tab.

Does Instagram rank carousels above Reels?

Instagram's 31 May 2023 ranking explainer names no format preference. It says the feed shows a mix of videos, photos and carousels.

Sources

  1. The State of Social Media Engagement in 2026: 52M+ Posts Analyzed, Buffer. Checked November 5, 2026.
  2. Socialinsider: Instagram engagement benchmarks, Socialinsider, 2026-02-20. Checked November 5, 2026.
  3. Who Needs Videos Anyway? Carousels Are Making a Major Comeback, Fanpage Karma, 2025-06-20. Checked November 5, 2026.
  4. Instagram Ranking Explained, Instagram, 2023-05-31. Checked November 5, 2026.
  5. Share a post with multiple photos or videos on Instagram, Instagram Help Center. Checked November 5, 2026.
  6. Fyslide FAQ, Fyslide. Checked November 13, 2026.